Management of Sports Injuries

What Has Changed in 30 Years of Clinical Sports Medicine

Speakers: Dr Peter Brukner and Dr Karim Khan

Host: Yara, Customer Success Manager, McGraw Hill

Prepared by: Dr Allison Kirsop, Scientific Writers Ltd

This summary records the content of the McGraw Hill webinar "Management of Sports Injuries", hosted by Yara, Customer Success Manager at McGraw Hill, with speakers Dr Peter Brukner and Dr Karim Khan, co-authors of the Clinical Sports Medicine series. It is written for practicing clinicians and physiotherapists managing musculoskeletal and sports injuries, in sport and exercise medicine, physiotherapy, rehabilitation and related disciplines.

Where a named program, agreement or publication was mentioned, a published source is cited so that it can be checked at source before being applied in practice. Points the speakers themselves flagged as uncertain, contested or opinion are identified as such and several of the topics below are areas where the speakers emphasized that the evidence does not yet support firm recommendations.

Speakers

  • Dr Peter Brukner — sport and exercise physician, Professor of Sports Medicine at La Trobe University, Melbourne. Founding partner of the Olympic Park Sports Medicine Centre; team doctor for Australia at the Olympic Games and FIFA World Cup; former Head of Sports Medicine and Sports Science at Liverpool Football Club; former Australian cricket team doctor. Awarded the Medal of the Order of Australia (2006) and 2025 VIC Senior Australian of the Year.
  • Dr Karim Khan — sport and exercise physician, Professor at the University of British Columbia, Vancouver, and Scientific Director of Musculoskeletal Health and Arthritis Research (2017-2025). Editor of the British Journal of Sports Medicine from 2008 to 2020; honorary doctorates from the Norwegian School of Sport Sciences, University of Edinburgh, and McGill University; Officer of the Order of Australia (2019). Dr Khan noted during the session that he has retired from clinical practice.

Structure of the sixth edition: which volume for which reader

Dr Khan explained that the sixth edition of Clinical Sports Medicine is split across three different books, and that the distinction matters when selecting texts for a course so that students do not "buy the wrong book by mistake" [1].

Clinical Sports Medicine: Foundations of Clinical Practice (For students and those early in practice) [1]

Described by Dr Khan as aimed at university/college students and those learning the principles of sport and exercise medicine, physiotherapy, rehabilitation and massage therapy. It was published in 2025 and its content includes:

  • How to function as a clinician: listening, caring for a team, shared decision making, synthesizing evidence, and learning from experienced clinicians.
  • Fundamental sciences of the field: athlete education, load management, injury prevention.
  • Principles of treatment and rehabilitation, including surgery and exercise therapy.

Dr Khan stated the volume is 440 pages and priced at USD 65, and that it has appeared in sports medicine bestseller lists in several countries. The cover image of sprinters leaving the starting blocks was described as a deliberate metaphor for clinicians beginning their careers.

Clinical Sports Medicine: Managing Injuries (For practicing clinicians) [2]

Dr Brukner described this volume as retaining the structure used since the series began in the 1990s. It is organized from head to toe and symptom-based, on the reasoning that "people don't present with a shoulder injury, they present with shoulder pain". Each chapter follows a consistent sequence:

  1. Overview of the relevant anatomy
  2. Potential causes of the symptom
  3. Making the diagnosis (history, examination, investigations)
  4. Management, with a particular focus on rehabilitation and return to sport

Because the principles of load management, exercise prescription, and similar techniques are covered in the Foundations volume, they are not repeated here.

Authorship and the evidence-experience balance

Dr Brukner stated that Managing Injuries has approximately 85 co-authors, chosen as leading international experts in their areas, with the editors overseeing each chapter for consistency of format. He framed the central editorial challenge as balancing expert clinical experience with research evidence: "we don't want to make it totally research based... and we don't want to make it totally devoid of evidence."

Both speakers noted the series is revised roughly every five years, and that each revision reveals more change than anticipated. Dr Brukner contrasted the current edition with the first, published in 1993.

Illustration, figures and linked resources

Dr Khan highlighted custom-drawn, annotated artwork by illustrator Vicky Earle as a deliberate value and teaching decision, and stated the new volume contains around 1,500 figures, including photographic exercise sequences. He said rehabilitation programs are laid out so that a clinician can review one before seeing a patient and reported that junior physiotherapists had told them they use the material to prepare the night before a busy clinic.

The speakers also described QR codes in the text pointing to selected external resources, with the stated rationale that curated links offer students a trustworthy route to further reading. The host added that both volumes are available digitally on McGraw Hill's AccessPhysiotherapy platform, alongside Brukner and Khan video and audio collections.

Topic 1: Concussion

How practice has shifted

Dr Brukner described the change over his career as substantial. Early in his practice, concussion was widely regarded as a reversible condition without long-term consequences and, in his words, "wasn't treated with enough respect"; management was "gung-ho", with players sometimes returning to the field the same day after answering a few questions.

He credited the Concussion in Sport consensus conferences with driving change, and identified three current features of practice:

  • Standardized diagnosis, with SCAT tests used internationally, giving greater consistency.
  • More conservative management: any symptoms preclude return to play on the day of injury, followed by a defined period away from sport and a graduated return over approximately one to two weeks.
  • Time-based minimum stand-down periods set by many professional and community leagues. Dr Brukner cited examples of 8, 14 or 21 days depending on the competition.

Persistent symptoms after concussion

Dr Brukner said most concussions resolve within a day or two of rest followed by graduated return. He estimated that approximately 10% of people remain symptomatic after three or four weeks — explicitly qualifying this as his own estimate — and described these as post-concussion symptoms.

These people present a great challenge, and he identified concussion as the area of greatest recent progress describing the approach as determining which system or systems are contributing to symptoms, then treating that system specifically. Such systems include vestibular, visual, cervical spine, headache disorders, mental health and autonomic. Vestibular rehabilitation programs were given as one example, and he attributed the relevant chapter to Kathryn Schneider, whom he described as the world expert in this area of rehabilitation [3].

Chronic traumatic encephalopathy: a contested area

Dr Brukner described chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) as controversial. He characterized two extreme positions — that everyone who sustains concussions will develop CTE, and that CTE does not exist — and stated his own view that the truth lies somewhere in between. He credited Dr John Patricios, a sport and exercise medicine physician in South Africa, as lead author of this section of the book, who gives a balanced view.

He raised the point of how historical cases largely reflect football codes of 20 to 40 years ago, when concussion management was very different, so whether contemporary management prevents long-term sequelae is not yet known.

Topic 2: Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and other knee injuries

Dr Khan framed the discussion with the recollection that, during Dr Brukner's years as a professional football team doctor, surgeons considered the fastest return from ACL surgery was treated as a badge of honor.

What has not improved

Dr Brukner listed successive claimed breakthroughs such as artificial ligaments, and various accelerated rehabilitation protocols, and stated that none of the accelerated techniques has proven successful. Return-to-sport timelines remain roughly 8 months in some sports and 12 months in many; with a recurrence rate he described as still higher than desirable regardless of surgical or rehabilitation quality.

He emphasized that, "you can't really change biology... these tissues take time to heal," adding that attempts to accelerate healing may succeed eventually, but have not yet.

What has improved

  • Quality of rehabilitation. Dr Brukner contrasted six weeks of post-surgical immobilization followed by three months regaining lost range of motion with today's early mobilization and functional rehabilitation. From his professional football experience, he reported that players formerly struggled through their first season back and rarely regained their previous standard, whereas now they appear to "slot straight in".
  • Prevention. He cited Prep to Play, developed at La Trobe University, Melbourne, Australia, as a program with evidence of effectiveness — carefully qualified as "not preventing all knee injuries". Its focus is specific warm-up exercises and technique for jumping, landing and tackling [4].

The adherence problem

Dr Brukner identified the main barrier to prevention as behavioral rather than scientific: getting coaches, fitness staff and players to commit to the exercises, when players "just want to go and kick a football". He argued the field's priority should be persuading coaches and support staff to adopt programs that already exist, given that a 12-month absence can be career-defining.

Is surgery always needed?

Dr Brukner said that for many years surgery was assumed for all ACL injuries, with the only debate being immediate versus delayed surgery with pre-rehabilitation. He described growing evidence that not everyone requires surgery and that cases should be evaluated individually, with some patients doing well on conservative management.

He described the Cross Bracing Protocol, developed by Dr Tom Cross, a sport and exercise physician in Sydney, with orthopedic surgeon Merv Cross, as effective for ACL injuries meeting certain criteria but not all [5]. He was explicit about the limits of the claim: "we're not saying everyone should do that, or that the evidence is 100% there", stating that part of the textbook's role is to introduce new therapies and assess their pros and cons.

Topic 3: Hamstring, calf and quadriceps injuries

The problem has not been solved

Dr Brukner described hamstring injury as probably the most common injury affecting elite athletes — more common than ACL injury, though with less impact per case — and said incidence has not been reduced despite substantially increased knowledge. Dr Khan referenced UEFA injury data and the prominence of hamstring injuries in the World Cup and Premier League.

Dr Brukner's stated interpretation is that the intensity of the football codes is rising rapidly, citing intense pressing in soccer, and that improving knowledge is keeping pace with rising intensity but not getting ahead of it: "We're not winning. We're not getting ahead of it. So, if we weren't increasing our knowledge, it would be a disaster."

What understanding has changed: the intramuscular tendon

Dr Brukner described the historical pattern as treating all hamstring injuries the same way and returning players once symptom-free at three or four weeks, with a substantial proportion of injuries recurring for reasons that were unclear.

The explanation he described rests on revised anatomical understanding, assisted considerably by MRI. Muscle injuries occur at muscle-tendon junctions, but hamstring injuries clinically appeared in the muscle belly. The explanation is that the proximal and distal tendons extend some way into the muscle as intramuscular tendons, so injuries occur at the junction between muscle fibers and these intramuscular structures — anatomically a muscle-tendon junction, clinically presenting mid-belly.

He added that where the tendon itself is partially or completely torn, those cases take longer to rehabilitate and are more likely to recur. He suggested that athletes historically affected by repeated hamstring injuries in the past may have had this pathology unrecognized. He had previously questioned the value of MRI for hamstring injury and now considers imaging findings important in identifying the differences and subtleties that affect time out of sport, rehabilitation aggressiveness and recurrence risk.

He noted a suggestion that intramuscular tendon injuries are becoming more common, possibly because muscles are now so strong that tendons cannot cope. He described this as a theory rather than established, with his own comment, "that's possible, so again, we've got a lot to learn."

Prevention: two elements

Dr Brukner identified strength and speed as the two elements of hamstring prevention. Hamstrings must be strong, and athletes must be exposed to high-speed running in preparation, stating "you can't just run at three-quarter pace and then go out and play a game of football and expect to run at full pace."

Calf and quadriceps

He stated that equivalent structures such as intramuscular tendons and aponeuroses in the calf are associated with poorer outcomes, and that an understanding of calf and quadriceps injuries has improved. He described hamstring, calf and quadriceps as the three major lower-limb muscle injuries, with dedicated book illustrations for each.

Topic 4: Groin pain

The Doha agreement as a turning point

Dr Brukner described the Doha agreement of 2014 as "a game changer", resolving widespread confusion about diagnostic entities and labelling for groin pathology, crediting Adam Weir and colleagues [6]. He singled out the accompanying illustration as the most quoted and most reused image of the series, appearing in effectively every lecture on groin or hip he had attended in the subsequent 13 years or so.

The one area described as improving

Asked whether the field is winning, Dr Brukner's assessment was that groin injuries are the clearest success: less prevalent than before, and fundamentally an overload issue. He acknowledged:

  • Copenhagen exercises, which he compared to Nordic exercises for hamstrings, used by most elite football teams in warm-ups for groin prevention, also in rehabilitation and return to sport.
  • Load management. He stated he did not hear the term "load" in his first 20 years in sport and that it was not a concept people understood, whereas it is now central to both prevention and return to sport. Both books, Foundations of Clinical Practice and Managing Injuries emphasize the importance of managing load.

Asked directly whether exercise rehabilitation is first line for groin pain, he agreed that it was. He acknowledged a small role for surgery and injection and stated that exercise rehabilitation is the key to the management of essentially all soft tissue injuries, including post-operatively.

Topic 5: Low back pain

Separating two different problems

Dr Brukner described low back pain as the most common musculoskeletal disorder in society, affecting virtually everyone at some stage. He noted that early editions of the book managed it largely with electrotherapy and manual therapy, whereas current programs are largely exercise-based, adding that he still considers manual therapy to have a role.

He outlined a spectrum of opinion. At one end, low back pain is mechanical and requires mechanical solutions; at the other, the biopsychosocial model of chronic pain. He credited Peter O'Sullivan and colleagues as pioneers of the biopsychosocial concept and as contributors to the low back pain chapter.

The editorial decision he emphasized is the deliberate separation of:

  • Chronic low back pain — a major societal issue, but less prominent in sport.
  • Acute low back pain — defined by him as short history or sudden onset rather than by severity, and the main presentation in sport.

He stated the two are managed quite differently, while acknowledging they can overlap when acute pain becomes chronic. He attributed the acute low back pain section to Dr Larissa Trease, a doctor at the Australian Institute of Sport, and Kelly Wilkie, a physiotherapist who has worked with the Australian rowing team, describing the content as simple and straightforward but effective, with the goal of preventing progression to chronic pain.

On imaging he offered advice worth quoting directly: "treat the patient, not the MRI."

Pars stress fractures

Dr Brukner described stress fractures of the pars interarticularis as an epidemic among cricket fast bowlers, and common in other sports involving hyperextension and rotation, naming gymnastics and high jump. He said this section draws on those who have worked with Australian cricket fast bowlers over many years, covering diagnosis, management and return to sport. He also noted an increased emphasis across all chapters on graduated return to sport, replacing an older surgical assumption that repair alone permitted return to play.

Rapid-fire questions from the speakers' exchange

Dry needling

Dr Brukner stated a clear personal position. He finds dry needling very effective for tight soft tissue bands and trigger points, while noting it is not the only option and that manual pressure can serve the same purpose. He explicitly described the research as equivocal and the intervention as very hard to research, referring to his own sham-needling project. He reported that increasing numbers of physical therapists use it for more chronic, low-grade pain.

Diet, inflammation and lifestyle

Dr Brukner said he had not until relatively recently appreciated how many conditions treated by doctors and physical therapists are inflammatory in nature. He summarized his position as favoring a "real food diet" and eliminating processed and ultra-processed foods, naming sugar, vegetable oils and certain grains as containing components he considers inflammatory. He reported clinical successes managing inflammatory conditions through improved diet and a recently completed research project on diet and osteoarthritis with results he described as encouraging.

He also listed sleep as under-emphasized, along with smoking, alcohol, inactivity and sunshine, mentioning interest in the role of sunshine beyond vitamin D, including nitric oxide. He closed the topic by stating there is still a great deal not fully understood.

Audience questions

Balancing evidence-based guidelines against pressure for rapid return to play

Dr Khan declined to answer on the grounds that he has retired from clinical practice. Dr Brukner responded:

  • Elite sport carries real pressure to perform, and management is always a compromise. If clinicians waited for every professional athlete to be entirely free of niggles, "they probably wouldn't play very often".
  • Every case is a separate decision, and the pathology must be respected first: "if you've got an injury, you can't ignore the pathology."
  • Factors to weigh include individual tolerance of a given injury, whether an injury is one that can safely be played with, and the importance of the event.
  • He illustrated the point with a current example of an England player withdrawing from World Cup competition with a calf injury, inferring the injury must have been significant, while others with minor injuries continue effectively.
  • He described this balance as the biggest challenge of working in professional sport, with coach and player pushing to play, and a clinician's duty at times to "protect them against themselves".

Technology and digital health

Dr Brukner identified wearables as the major advance, used by athletes and the wider fitness industry principally to measure load. He named GPS as the obvious example, now used well beyond elite sport, and said a broader range of information is now derived from GPS than when it first appeared. He expects continued sophistication, with application to load management in both quantity and quality — that is, endurance and speed — and therefore to prevention, rehabilitation and return to sport.

One key message from each author

Asked what single message a clinician should take from the sixth edition:

Dr Khan — commitment to exercise as fundamental to successful healing. He contrasted this with the promise of electrotherapy in the 1990s (which proved largely ineffective) and with orthobiologics today, stating, "the evidence is not matching the hype”. He referred to mechanotherapy — the concept that loading tissues is proven at the cellular level to promote tissue repair – describing the core message of the 6th edition as advocating careful assessment using clinical skills to identify the problem, then focused rehabilitation with strengthening and range of motion. He anticipated the objection that these were the fundamentals of the 1990s, answering that this is biology, and "if you address the right problem with appropriate load progression, it will be good." His closing observation, from knowing many of the world's leading clinicians, is that what distinguishes them is performing the basics extremely well.

Dr Brukner — prevention. Both primary prevention and secondary prevention, meaning rehabilitating an injury to the point where recurrence does not occur. He described this as a major focus of the last two editions and particularly the current 6th edition.

Conclusion

On the speakers' own assessment, groin pain is the clear success, attributed to diagnostic clarity from the Doha agreement, specific preventive exercise, and the adoption of load management. Concussion management has changed substantially in diagnosis, stand-down policy and the treatment of persisting symptoms. ACL and hamstring injuries show markedly improved understanding and rehabilitation quality without corresponding reductions in time loss or recurrence, which Dr Brukner attributes to the limits of biology and, for hamstrings, to rising competitive intensity.

Three themes cut across every topic and bear directly on day-to-day practice:

  1. Anatomical and diagnostic precision changes management. The intramuscular tendon in hamstring injury and the Doha terminology for groin pain both show that better classification, not new treatment, is what drove the change in practice.
  2. Exercise rehabilitation and load progression are the core, not the adjunct. Both authors converged on this independently, with Dr Khan grounding it in mechanotherapy and Dr Brukner extending it to essentially all soft tissue and post-operative management.
  3. Implementation is a clinical skill. The stated barrier to ACL and hamstring prevention is not the absence of effective programs but the difficulty of persuading coaches, support staff and athletes to use them — which places adherence, not program selection, at the center of the clinician’s preventive work.

The speakers were also consistent in signaling that there are uncertainties in the field: equivocal evidence for dry needling, an unproven theory about strength and intramuscular tendon injury, and not overstating the evidence behind the Cross Bracing Protocol. That discipline is itself instructive for practice. On Dr Khan’s account, what distinguishes the world’s leading clinicians is not novel intervention but doing the basics exceptionally well – assessing the patient carefully, identifying the functional limitation, loading tissue with appropriate progression, and remaining precise about the boundary between what is known and what is merely believed.