Full Podcast Transcript:
Holly Luky:
Hello, friends, and welcome to another episode of our Management Insights Podcast from McGraw-Hill. I'm your host, Holly Luky, and today we're excited to bring you another great topic from one of our management authors, Michael Peters, co-author of one of our leading entrepreneurship titles. Mike joins us today to discuss business plan strategy for starting a small business. Mike holds a PhD from the University of Massachusetts Amherst and is a retired faculty member of Boston College's Carroll School of Management. With over 40 years of international experience in consulting and teaching small-business start-ups, he has developed MBA entrepreneurship programs at Boston College and the American College of Greece, published two textbooks and over 30 academic articles, as well as served on multiple corporate and family business boards. Please welcome, Mike Peters.
Mike Peters:
Thank you, Holly. I'm really pleased to be here. And it's interesting for me at least in terms of looking at this particular example that we've taken something that people think of entrepreneurship as being really huge companies. We don't think of these very, very small businesses, and this is really a good example of an application of this framework that I've used to start a small business.
Holly Luky:
Yeah, this one is really interesting to me. So, for our listeners, today we're going to discuss a framework for developing a business plan and strategy for starting a small business that Mike used when starting a preschool. So, Mike, can you please give us an overview of this framework?
Mike Peters:
Yeah, it's pretty simple, actually. I've used this so often with entrepreneurs who have been to my office or in terms of working with some of them overseas, is to say, "It's really a simple process that you can apply to almost anything." And later on, I'll share with you some of my thoughts on how this particular approach can help in terms of real life. But, basically, it's three questions. The first question is where are we now? Second question, where are we going? And the third question is how do we get there? And if you think of it in terms of business planning, a lot of people argue that when you're in such a small business that the need to develop a very complicated and cumbersome business plan is really not worthwhile. And a lot of people talk about the fact that business plans are unnecessary. But I think if you look at these three questions and you apply them to a startup business, it's really taking you through what a business plan would really be all about.
And if you don't document them into a hundred pages or even three pages, at least you're giving consideration to these three questions, which I think are so important in starting a business. If we take the first question is where are we now? And I'm going to look at this in terms of my wife and I started a preschool over 40 years ago, believe it or not, and it's been very successful. And when we were back at that particular time, we really were in a situation, we had two young children. So if we were asking ourselves the question, where are we now? Basically we had two young children. One of them was just about to go into kindergarten. The second one was really ready for preschool. And my wife started considering preschools in the town that we lived in. Unfortunately, there were huge waiting lists.
Eventually, my youngest was able to get into this particular program in our town. My wife was asked at the time if, because of her background and her education, if she might be interested in subbing, which she agreed to do. So she was subbing and my youngest daughter was a student in this preschool. My wife, many times we sat and talked about and said, "The fact is that these programs are very stoic, very standardized. Basically children were given things to color, things to draw, not much learning going on. The waiting lists were incredible." And we started to talk about, "Maybe we could think about starting a preschool." Where are we now? Well, she needed to do some things. One thing was in order to start a school, she would need to add to her education, which meant state requirements for particular courses that she would have to take.
So, basically, at this point, her experience in working as a sub, going back to school kind of set the motion into the second question, where are we going? So in terms of where are we going, you have to think about where would the best location be? And the best location really goes back to the fact that here we are in the particular town we lived in and there is a very long waiting list. We lived in a town where there were a lot of young children, a lot of new housing, a lot of the people that were moving to the suburbs into the area where we lived were first-time home users, so it meant young children. So we started to think about this and said maybe we could consider looking at some local towns where we have the same kind of situation as we had in our town, meaning new homes, lots of new home users, lots of young children.
And so we started looking at this. We started talking to real estate agents. We started to think about the fact that many, many of the spouses were, we had two working people in a family with young children looking for schools and places where the children could go. So, basically, at this point we're saying, "Where are we now?" We're in a situation where there looks like there's a lot of opportunities. We also were unhappy with the teaching methods that my wife had observed. We certainly were aware of the fact that many of our friends and families in the town that we lived in were two-spouse working families, working people. And here we are now with my wife having had some teaching experience and going back to school to get the requirements needed to teach and to manage a preschool, kind of set us into the motion of this second question that I mentioned.
And so we started to talk to where are we going? We started to talk to real estate agents. We started to look at the newspapers, local newspapers to see what kind of new housing was being developed. We looked at the towns, various towns' populations. And so we began to think about the best location. And in doing so, we had to also consider things like should we rent, should we buy? Where would be the most likely place to locate a preschool? And fortunately, when we looked around at some of the competition, most of the preschools were located in churches. So we started to consider churches, towns that were showing growth, a lot of new home building, a lot of new construction, real estate agents arguing with us or telling us that these are towns that have a lot of young children. So our criteria at this point in terms of where we're going was we needed a town that showed this kind of growth.
We needed a town that had a church and maybe a location where we could open the preschool and also a town where there wasn't any major competition. And from that, we kind of set our minds on one particular town, which was an adjacent town to where we lived. At this point, we said, "Okay, it looks like we've kind of located the place where we would like to be. We certainly have a sense of where we're going now because my wife has gotten the experience needed. She's gotten the education and the courses that she needed." So we started to do some more research and the research really was doing some local surveys. We were fortunate in that one of the churches that we identified was a Congregational Church in the adjacent town and it had classrooms that were being used for Sunday School. There were actually four classrooms, and those classrooms were basically not being used for anything else except Sunday Schools.
So this looked like a good opportunity for us. So with the help of the church, we surveyed many of the congregation. We also went out to some of the malls and to the local schools and basically ended up with a sample of surveys to find out exactly whether this would be a good opportunity. Now, I want to mention here, a lot of people would argue, "Well, is this really a statistically-valid survey?" Probably not, although the data that we got all pretty much said the same thing, that basically this was an opportunity, that people needed it, and therefore the survey results were what we were basically thinking. It agreed with what we were thinking. So that takes us-
Holly Luky:
Can I just ask you a quick question?
Mike Peters:
Yeah, sure.
Holly Luky:
So it sounds like you were really at this stage focusing on who your audience is, what are the demographics, and then backing it up with surveys, market research. So were you doing these as physical surveys, like on a piece of paper and chatting with them one-on-one?
Mike Peters:
Yes. I'm just curious how you rolled that out.
Holly Luky:
Okay. Wow.
Mike Peters:
Yeah, no, this was done the old way with basically paper surveys instead of something digital that you'd find today. And basically we were stopping people in malls and the schools and asking them if they were interested in a preschool and if it was something that, you know, if they had young children, we tried to determine whether our thoughts about the growth of this particular town and whether the fact was that we had many young children there. And it all came back to us with the same basically conclusion that this was a good place to locate. We had the church with the four classrooms and we had certainly an audience or a potential population of people out there that would fill the classrooms very easily. So that's kind of where we're at in terms of where we are going. So the second question is really being answered through all of this particular analysis.
Holly Luky:
Great, great. Thank you for that. Thank you for expanding upon it.
Mike Peters:
Okay. Now we're at the point where we're saying, "We needed a lot of things to get done." So the third question of, "How do we get there?" really took us into an area where we were a little bit unsure and uncertain. For example, licensing. The State of Massachusetts where this would be, obviously, located has certain regulations about licensing, so we need to consider all of the issues with regard to getting a license to operate a preschool. We needed certainly to set up an organization for the preschool. The question was what kind of structure?
At that time there were, I don't know if a lot of people may have heard of or recognized the fact that when you have young children, there's a very high risk of liability if an accident happens or a child is injured. So we needed to be sure that whatever type of organization structure we established that we would be protected in terms of liability. So we ended up incorporating. So we set up a corporation, we hired a lawyer to do this. We issued stock in my wife's name and my name, and we now had a name, which was the Green Meadows School, and that's what we did with the help of the lawyer. Second thing-
Holly Luky:
That's lovely. Very inviting.
Mike Peters:
Yeah. The second thing we needed to, besides the licensing, we also needed to negotiate with the church. They had four classrooms. We didn't think in terms of the first year of startup that we would be able to utilize all four classrooms. So in terms of negotiation, we had to determine whether if we were going to rent, would we rent all four classrooms or would we rent one or two classrooms in the beginning. Because at that point, even though we had the data from the surveys, we weren't sure exactly how many students we would end up with in the first year. As it turns out, we agreed with the church to start off with two classrooms and with the potential or option to expand at a later date. We then proceeded to initiate the licensing process with the Department of Early Childhood Education, and it gets pretty complicated.
The paperwork is incredible. So my wife who had now had more experience certainly than I did in terms of the licensing part, really set about in taking care of all the paperwork, and that took some time. We then had to think about hiring. We needed teachers, and even for the classrooms itself, not only would you need a teacher, but possibly an aide. My wife, as the director of the school in the State of Massachusetts, would not be allowed to actually teach. Her responsibility would be to manage the school. So we had to think about all of these things. And one of the things that my wife said that we would do is to appoint, once we hired the teachers and the school began to function profitably, is that she would hire an assistant to help her with some of the day-to-day responsibility as a director.
And that's kind of where we were marketing. We had to think about how would we market the school? We needed to somehow initiate contact with all these people who said yes, they'd be interested in a preschool, but how are we going to get them there to actually sign up? There were a number of things that we did. First of all, we set a date for an open house. We also, at that point, we spread flyers all over town. Every place that we could, we put up flyers.
Holly Luky:
Love it. Yeah.
Mike Peters:
We put an ad in a local newspaper, and the church made an announcement at their church service, which also helped us. I might say, in terms of backing up a little bit here, that not only when you think about starting a preschool, yes, the Sunday School had some tables and had some chairs, but we were going to need a lot of other furniture. So we also had to think about making a list of what we needed to buy. So there was a lot of up-front expense involved in trying to find the appropriate ... We needed books for the children. We certainly needed a lot of supplies. My wife was able to establish an account with ... There are a couple of children supply companies that exist, and to be able to, once you set up the account and you buy in certain types of quantity, sometimes you can get good discounts.
So we needed to do that. We needed cabinets to be able to store all of the supplies that you were going to need for the children. So there's a lot of little things that oftentimes you don't think about, and that's why I feel very strongly about the three questions, because if you really sit down and make a list under each question, it's amazing how you realize that there are things that need to get done that you probably wouldn't have thought about. So anyhow, we had the open house. Things went very well. We ended up filling two classrooms the first year. By the second and third year, we had all four classrooms operating. And at one time, the way the school was set up, children come nine to three Monday through Friday, or they can come Monday, Wednesday, Friday mornings, or they can come Monday, Wednesday, Friday afternoons, or they can come only Tuesday, Thursday.
So one of the things that happens is a lot of the families didn't necessarily want their children in all five days, but we were set up so that they could take a part-time approach. And the interesting thing about all of this is when you license for a preschool, you're actually licensed for a daycare center, but my wife was not interested in really doing anything below the age of two years, nine months to just pre-kindergarten. And that's basically what the preschool, or sometimes they've referred to as nursery schools, really are. Well, people ask and say, "Well, what kind of market do you really have for something like this?" Well, it's surprising because a lot of the spouses are working part-time, particularly the wife in that instance where you have young children might be looking at part-time job. They may have grandparents that are local that are living nearby.
They may have nannies, they may have whatever, taking care of the children when they're not in school. One of the things that we did is we set up a list of people that would be willing to ... For example, one of the things you could get into is whether or not you should have transportation, and we did not want to get into transportation at all because of the liability. But what we did do-
Holly Luky:
Sure.
Mike Peters:
... is we set up a program where parents who were willing to drive other children in their neighborhood who were also students at the school, so they could sign up for this and be responsible for getting the children to the school at whatever days they were there. And that's kind of where we were at. And as I said, the school flourished and is still in operation today as we speak, so ...
Holly Luky:
Fantastic. That's wonderful. Do you have any personal connection to it anymore?
Mike Peters:
Oh, yeah.
Holly Luky:
Yeah? Okay.
Mike Peters:
We still have a personal ... We have a full-time director and an assistant director. My wife is basically sort of retired from the day-to-day, although she does a lot of the ordering, takes care of any of the specific needs and helping with hiring aides and teachers and things of that sort. My responsibility has been more financial. I do all the payroll. I've helped with the marketing and setting up some of the social-media stuff that we've been doing. And basically the school has, with the help of some really good staff, has continued to operate successfully.
Holly Luky:
That's fantastic. What a great story and what a wonderfully unique example. I think a lot of our listeners can relate to being able to choose schools and see what's available and understand the conundrum when something isn't available in their area. So this falls right within that, what problem am I trying to solve for my community? And it's very important in the community, so thank you for sharing that with us. I know you mentioned that these three questions or framework is also applicable to everyday life. I was wondering if you could expand upon that.
Mike Peters:
Yeah. I used to tell my students all the time and saying to them, "Look, these three questions can be very important in your day-to-day responsibilities." And I usually point to two examples. Number one is, if you are preparing your final graduation and what you're going to do with the rest of your life, these are three questions you should be asking yourself. So when you think about where am I now, the question is what kind of background, what kind of experience? Do you have internships? So when you're putting together your resume, you're really responding to these three questions.
It's important to get on paper all of your experience and anything else that's part of your education, special courses, if you've spent time abroad, anything else that you do in the community, all that is part of where you're at now. Where are you going? You obviously have to establish some thoughts of what particular type of career you're looking at, setting some goals. These are also important as part of your resume, as part of your thinking in terms of your career. How do we get there? So now you're getting to the strategy of a student graduating from college in terms of setting up interviews, going back, making contacts, references, anything else that can be utilized to get you to where you want to be. So that was one application. The other application I use, which is kind of unique because I think it's a little bit more, I think, appropriate in terms of application to starting a business, and that's think about if you wanted to plan a vacation and here we are on the East Coast and we want to travel across country.
Well, where are we now? First of all, we got to think about, have I ever done anything like this before? What kind of transportation is available and how much money do I have available in terms of a vacation such as this? And do I have time available? These are all things that you look at in terms of your own situation as it exists. So where are we now? Where are we going? Well, we're going across country, let's say from Massachusetts to California, and in doing so, there's a lot of different ways that you can get there. So even though we're going from Massachusetts to California, and there are different ways that you can do that, how do we get there becomes a very important question. Do we drive? Do we take trains? Do we take airplanes? We also recognize in order to get from Massachusetts to California, you can go many different ways.
You can go through the northern part of the United States, you can go right through the middle of the United States. There are many places you might want to stop. So in terms of how you get there, you recognize that there are actually different ways to get from Massachusetts to California. And I make this argument to the students to simply say that the same thing is true with starting a business. There are many ways to get to where you want to go. I mean, we could have done things a little differently in terms of the preschool. Maybe we could have thought about buying a facility and converting it. We may have thought about more hours, daycare. So, basically, I wanted my students to recognize the fact that to get where you're going, there are different options and you always obviously have to choose one, but don't ever have any regret. I mean, the important thing is you make that decision when you get to that fork in the road basically, and you've got to follow through. And so that's really the two examples that I often use with my students.
Holly Luky:
Wow, that's really interesting. Don't have the regret. Keep going. See it through.
Mike Peters:
Yes. I hope that's all been very useful, so ...
Holly Luky:
Oh, I think so. I think there were a lot of great takeaways, but I do like to always ask as we near the end of our conversation today, what is the biggest takeaway you hope our listeners have from this conversation?
Mike Peters:
Well, I think the biggest takeaway is the fact that my last point was that there are many, many ways to start a business. There are many reasons that you start a business. The takeaway is that there are opportunities to recognize what those opportunities are and then to apply these three questions. I think anybody who is ever thinking about starting a business has to somehow make the personal argument and address these three questions in some way. Even if it's not, as I said, it doesn't have to be a business plan that's a hundred pages. It might be simply an outline or thoughts on paper, but more importantly, it forces the individual to address what are the important issues to make sure that any kind of business opportunity will have its best chance for success.
Holly Luky:
Yeah, absolutely. Well, thank you so much, Mike. I've really enjoyed our conversation today-
Mike Peters:
Okay. I-
Holly Luky:
... and I'm so grateful you're sharing your strategy with our listeners.
Mike Peters:
Okay. I hope I haven't rambled too much, but ...
Holly Luky:
No, it's just right. Thanks again.