Skip to main content

McGraw Hill Literacy

McGraw Hill Literacy Author Spotlight:
Dr. Douglas Fisher

On comprehension, purposeful practice, and helping every student take ownership of learning

We believe the people behind a program matter as much as the program itself. That's why we're launching a series of introductions to the researchers, educators, and children's literature experts whose expertise, passion, and lived experience shaped our new comprehensive K–12 literacy suite, McGraw Hill Literacy.

Next in our author spotlight series is Dr. Douglas Fisher, Professor and Chair of Educational Leadership at San Diego State University and a leader at Health Sciences High & Middle College. A former early intervention teacher and elementary school educator, Dr. Fisher brings a classroom-grounded perspective to his work on comprehension, foundational skills, vocabulary, and writing. His publications span reading and literacy, differentiated instruction, and curriculum design. We sat down with him to talk about why advances in literacy instruction are less like a swinging pendulum and more like a deepening spiral, how teachers can support readers without reducing rigor, and what it takes to help students see themselves as capable learners who belong.

Dr. Fisher is also an author of our middle and high school literacy programs, Summit! and Soar!.  

You’ve described the field’s relationship with reading instruction as a spiral rather than a pendulum. What does that mean for educators tired of chasing the next shiny thing?

I often hear that in education there’s this pendulum, and it swings this way, and swings that way, and then swings back. I guess I just accepted that earlier in my career. But as I’ve spent time in the world of literacy, I think of it more like a drill. We come back around, but we go deeper this time. The things we know today about foundational skills are more robust than we knew last time. We know more about vocabulary today than we did in the past.

As I think about the work we do together to improve students’ literacy outcomes, we take the best knowledge and evidence, we take what our students need from us, and we use that evidence to improve outcomes. It’s not like we’re not paying attention to some things and only paying attention to other things, as a pendulum analogy would imply. Rather, we’re going deeper and deeper to meet the needs of our students.

I often hear that in education, there's this pendulum, and it swings this way and swings this way and then swings back. And I guess I just accepted that earlier in my career. But as I've spent time in the world of literacy, I think it more like a drill. We come back around, but we go deeper this time. And we come back around, and we go deeper this time. The things we know today about foundational skills are more robust than we knew last time we deeply dove into them. The things we know about vocabulary. We know more today about that than we did in the past. So as I think about the work we do together, the work on improving students' literacy outcomes, we take the best information, knowledge, evidence. We take what our students need from us, and we use that evidence to improve the outcomes. It's not like we're not paying attention to some things and only paying attention to other things, as a pendulum would imply, but rather we're going deeper and deeper to meet the needs of our students.

How can teachers help students put reading instruction into practice and build lasting habits as readers?

We know that you have to practice things to get good at things. Reading is no exception. But practice by itself probably is not going to change our performance. Yes, students need great instruction. They need learning time with you, and they need to engage in sufficient amounts of practice so that instruction can stick.

How do we get students to engage in actual reading, where their brains are paying attention to that text, figuring out the meaning, what it means to them, what the author is saying? That practice, much like soccer practice or baseball practice, is important. But practice doesn’t make perfect. Practice makes permanent. And what we want to create is permanent readers, who use all the skills, concepts, and strategies you taught them as they read increasingly complex texts.

We know that you have to practice things to get good at things. Reading is no exception. But practice by itself probably is not gonna change our performance. Yes. Students need great instruction. They need learning, time with you, and they need to engage in sufficient amounts of practice so that instruction can stick. This is important in reading. How do we get students to engage in actual reading, where their brains are paying attention to that text, figuring out the meaning, what it means to them, what the author is saying? That practice, much like soccer practice or baseball practice, is important. But practice does not make perfect. Practice makes permanent. And what we want to create is readerspermanent readerswho use all the skills, concepts, and strategies you taught them as they read increasingly complex texts.

Teachers often scaffold before the lesson by pre-teaching vocabulary or showing a video, and you’ve said that can reduce rigor. How should teachers think about scaffolding knowledge, especially when older students are tackling complex texts?

Scaffolding is an interesting idea. Yes, students need academic supports to be successful. We don’t want them to fail and fail and fail, because they’re not going to feel good about their learning. But we can over-scaffold and unintentionally reduce the rigor of the learning experience.

There are different ways to think about scaffolding. Some people call it front-end, distributed, and back-end. Where do the scaffolds get used? Before a lesson, during a lesson, or after a lesson? We tend to think primarily about front-end scaffolds, or things we do in advance to help students become successful. But what if they don’t all need that? What if we put in some front-end scaffolds and actually reduce the expectations for our students? So, we should also think about distributed scaffolds, or scaffolds that occur during the flow of the lesson. Now, if students start to experience failure after failure, we want to go back to some front-end scaffolds. I think of this as attention. We should always be thinking about what scaffolds will be required so students can take on the responsibility of their learning.

Scaffolding is an interesting idea. Yes, students need academic supports to be successful. We don't want to have them fail and fail and fail and fail because they're not going to feel good about their learning. But we can over scaffold and unintentionally reduce the rigor of the learning experience. There are ways to think about scaffolding. Some people call it front end, distributed, and back end. Where do the scaffolds get used? Is it before a lesson, during a lesson, or after a lesson? We tend to think about front end scaffolds, things we do in advance of the next lesson to help students become successful. But what if they don't all need that? What if we put in some front end scaffolds and actually reduce the expectations for our students? So we should think about also using distributed scaffolds, scaffolds that occur during the flow of the lesson. Now students start to experience failure after failure after failure, we want to go back to some front end scaffolds. I think of this as attention. We should always be thinking about what scaffolds will be required and what do I not have to do so students can take on the responsibility of their learning.

What role does knowledge play in comprehension, and how should teachers build and activate it?

Regardless of whether you look at the Reading Rope or the Simple View of Reading, the Active View of Reading, or the Reading Circuit, all of the reading models note the value of knowledge. Knowledge is an important contributor to your comprehension in reading. Our job is to be knowledge workers, to help students acquire that conceptual understanding, so they have some background, some prior knowledge, that will help them as they read.

Reading is one of the ways that you build background knowledge. But so are other kinds of experiences: things the teacher does, videos, visiting places, etc. All of that is building this rich knowledge base that students then need to learn how to activate when they read. We recognize that knowledge has an influence on understanding. How much you already know is predictive of how much you understand the next text you read. So, we have to think about: What is the essential knowledge students would have to know to understand this text? How do I develop or activate that knowledge so that students are successful in reading?

Regardless of whether you look at the reading rope or the simple view of reading, the active view of reading, the reading circuit, all of the reading models say and note the value of knowledge, that knowledge is an important contributor to your comprehension in reading. And our job is to be knowledge workers, to help students acquire that knowledge, that conceptual understanding, so they have some background, some prior knowledge that will help them as they read. Reading is one of the ways that you build background knowledge, but so are other kinds of experiences, things that the teacher does. Videos, visiting places, all of that is building this rich knowledge base that then students need to learn how to activate when they read. Because we recognize knowledge has an influence on your understanding. How much you already know is predictive of how much you understand the next text you read. So we have to think about what is the essential knowledge students would have to know to understand this text? How do I develop that or activate that knowledge so that students are successful in reading?

When students get frustrated and disengage from a lesson, how should teachers respond?

When we watch our students, we can see some of them get frustrated. They disengage and they check out of lessons. We have to learn to diagnose. What do we believe caused that disengagement? Is it their mindset: I’m not a good reader, I’m not a good writer? Is it that they believe this is not important, I don’t need to learn this to be successful in my life? Is it their multitasking? Is it that they got to cognitive overload?

If we think about this in a more diagnostic way – what contributed to that student’s disengagement? – then we can consider what actions we can take to reinvite that student into learning. I didn’t say this was easy! What I said is that if we get better at identifying what contributed to students’ disengagement, we can take actions to get them back into learning.

When we watch our students, we can see some of them get frustrated. They disengage. They check out of lessons. And we have to learn to diagnose. What do we believe caused that disengagement? Is it their mindset? I'm not a good reader. I'm not a good writer. Is it they believe this is not important? I don't need to learn this to be successful in my life. Is it they're multitasking? Is it that they got to cognitive overload? So if we think about this in a more diagnostic way, what contributed to that student's disengagement? And then what actions can we take to reinvite that student into learning? And I didn't say this is easy. I did not say that. What I said is, if we get better and better at identifying what contributed to students' disengagement, then there are actions we can take to get students back into learning. When students know what they're learning, they're more likely to focus on that aspect of what happens in their class. When they know what successful learning looks like, they're more likely to self assess. There's even evidence that when students feel comfortable with what they are learning, they feel safer in class, and their well-being goes up. There are all kinds of ways to communicate with students. What are we learning today, and what does successful learning look like? But the key is about building self regulation. When students know what they're learning and they know what successful learning looks like, they are way more likely to self regulate their behavior. And when they find that learning relevant, they're going to allocate their time, effort, resources to learning.

How does making learning goals and success criteria explicit change the way students participate in a lesson?

When students know what they’re learning, they’re more likely to focus on that aspect of what happens in their class. When they know what successful learning looks like, they’re more likely to self-assess. There’s even evidence that when students feel comfortable with what they are learning, they feel safer in class and their well-being goes up.

There are all kinds of ways to communicate with students what we’re learning today and what successful learning looks like. But the key is building self-regulation. When students know what they’re learning and what successful learning looks like, they are way more likely to self-regulate their behavior. And when they find that learning relevant, they’re going to allocate their time, effort, and resources to learning.

What’s one practical way teachers can give students more agency in their learning, without sacrificing rigor?

Do students believe that if they put forth effort, good things are going to happen to them? That requires that students have a goal. What is it that I need to learn or do? Do I believe I have the wherewithal to accomplish that? And if I do accomplish it, is it valuable to me? All three are important.

When we experience success, it does feel good, but it has to be something we valued for us to experience that success. So as teachers, are we helping students with their goals? Are we helping students develop the skills so they can apply them to what we’re learning? And do they see relevance and value in the learning?

I do think some students have a broken relationship between effort and impact. As teachers, we have to reconnect that for our students. When you wrote this opening paragraph, it completely captivated your reader. That feels really good. That’s the kind of reconnection we need. Your effort resulted in these outcomes, and it’s because of you. You had a goal, you had strategies to get there, and you accomplished it.

Agency in learning. Do students believe if they put forth effort, good things, things they care about or are going to happen to them? That aspect, that idea of agency in learning, requires that students have a goal. What is it that I need to learn or do? Do I believe I have the wherewithal to accomplish that? And if I do accomplish it, is it valuable to me? All three of those things are important. What is my goal? Do I have the belief that I can accomplish it? And if I do accomplish it, does it feel good to me? When we experience success, it does feel good, but it has to be something that we valued to experience that success. So as teachers, are we helping students with their goals? What are we learning? Are we helping students develop the skills so they can apply them to the things we're learning? And do they see relevance and value in the learning so when they do learn it, it reinforces their agency? I do think some students have a broken relationship between effort and impact. When you put forth this effort, here's the good things that happen. So as teachers, we have to reconnect that for our students. When you wrote this opening paragraph, it completely captivated your reader. That feels really good. That's the kind of reconnection we need. Your effort resulted in these outcomes, and it's because of you. You had a goal, you had strategies to get there, and you accomplished

What’s a specific action teachers can take in the first few minutes of a lesson to signal to every student that they belong and their learning matters?

Here’s my theory: Students belonging in school leads to their engagement. They’re willing to engage in the tasks and activities you design for them because they have a sense of belonging. When they engage in what you ask them to do, they learn more, the learning outcomes improve, and that reinforces their sense of belonging. It becomes a self-fulfilling, reinforcing cycle.

There are some very simple things teachers can do to send the message you belong here. There’s strong evidence that greeting students by name at the door sends a message: I see you, you’re important here. Having students take on jobs and responsibilities in the classroom says you are needed in this classroom. Ensuring that all students have opportunities to respond, called universal response opportunities, helps students feel seen. My teacher wants all of our answers, not just six or seven students’ answers. And when students work in a group, they should have roles and responsibilities. Am I necessary? Am I needed in this group?

Those are four quick ideas for sending the message you’re important here, you belong here, you matter. There are more complicated things we can do longer-term and school-wide, but belonging influences engagement, engagement influences learning outcomes, and those outcomes reinforce belonging.

Here's my theory. Belonging. Students' belonging in school leads to their engagement. They're willing to engage in the tasks and activities that you designed for them because they have a sense of belonging. And when they engage in what you ask them to do, they learn more. The learning outcomes improve. And when the learning outcomes improve, it reinforces our sense of belonging. In other words, it's a cycle that becomes self fulfilling and reinforcing. And there are some very simple things teachers can do to send a message, you belong here. Yes, there's some more complicated things as well. For example, there's strong evidence that greeting students by name at the door sends a message, I see you. You're important here. Having students have jobs, responsibilities in the classroom, says you're important here. You are needed in this classroom. Ensuring that all students have opportunities to respond, called universal response opportunities, help students feel seen. My teacher wants all of our answers, not just six or seven students' answers. And when they work in a group, they should have roles and responsibilities. Again, am I necessary? Am I needed to be in this group? So I gave you four quick ideas about how to send a message to students: You're important here. You belong here. You matter. Of course, there's more complicated things we can do longer term and school wide to send belonging messages to our students. But belonging influences their engagement, engagement influences their learning outcomes, and those outcomes reinforce their belonging.

What does a curriculum need in order to be useful and effective in the hands of great teachers? How do Emerge!, Summit!, and Soar! meet the moment?

From my perspective, lesson design is super important. We build on this theory of gradual release of responsibility. We design lessons to systematically, intentionally increase students’ responsibility for their learning.

We ensure that there are strong ways of developing language and literacy in each lesson. Students are actively reading, talking, and writing as each lesson unfolds. There’s a scope and sequence that ensures the concepts and skills required develop systematically through a progression of learning. Each of these helps the teacher make instructional decisions that improve outcomes for students.

What has to exist in a curriculum for it to be useful and effective. From my perspective, lesson design is super important. We build on this theory of gradual release of responsibility. We design lessons to systematically, intentionally increase students' responsibility for their learning. That's an important part. We ensure that there are strong ways of developing language and literacy in each lesson. Students are actively reading, talking, and writing as each lesson unfolds. There's a scope and sequence that ensures the concepts and skills required develop systematically through a progression of learning. Each of these helps the teacher make instructional decisions that improve the outcomes for students.

Dr. Douglas Fisher is Professor and Chair of Educational Leadership at San Diego State University and a leader at Health Sciences High & Middle College having been an early intervention teacher and elementary school educator. He is the recipient of an International Reading Association William S. Grey citation of merit, an Exemplary Leader award from the Conference on English Leadership of NCTE, as well as a Christa McAuliffe award for excellence in teacher education. He has published numerous articles on reading and literacy, differentiated instruction, and curriculum design as well as books, such as The Teaching Reading Playbook.

Top