Skip to main content

Florida Teacher Won't Face Charges for Showing R-Rated Film | December 2021

December 2021 | Volume 13, Issue 5


Read the full article from ABC News.

According to the article, a sheriff's investigation refutes allegations that a Florida Panhandle teacher subjected her students to pornography by letting them watch the R-rated movie “Alexander."

Parents of a 15-year-old girl told school officials she was traumatized by the Niceville High School teacher showing students a movie that they considered to be “porn."

But Okaloosa County Sheriff’s officials said there was no probable cause to bring charges against the teacher.

Investigators determined the teacher had a legitimate reason for showing the film to her college-level classical studies students. They also found the teacher had taken steps to limit what the students watched to keep underage students from viewing some of the more graphic scenes, the Northwest Florida Daily News reported.

The 2004 Oliver Stone movie stars Colin Farrell as ancient Greek king Alexander the Great. It contains nudity and scenes of sexual assault and homosexuality.

The teacher told investigators she knew which scenes they would see given the time they had in class to view the movie. She said those scenes were of battles and speeches, which would be a good resource for the students to reference for testing.

But after learning that a more family-friendly version of the movie was no longer available on Netflix, the teacher said she mistakenly obtained a “director’s cut” of the film.

The students who chose to watch the movie scenes when it was offered in September did so in a school hallway so they would not disturb the rest of the class. The students used the 15-year-old's laptop because it worked better than the school computers, the report said.

At the time, the girl was absent from school for two days and used her teacher's password to access an account and watch the movie from home, the newspaper reported. The couple and their daughter then watched the graphic scenes they later described to the Okaloosa County School Board as pornography.

Discussion Questions

  1. Define pornography.

    According to Britannica, pornography is generally defined as the representation of sexual behavior in books, pictures, statues, films, and other media that is intended to cause sexual excitement. Per the same site, the very definition of pornography is subjective, with pornography itself being “very much in the eye of the beholder.” United States Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart is famously quoted for characterizing pornography as “I know it when I see it.”
  2. To what extent, if at all, is pornography protected by the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution?

    Pornography receives limited protection under the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. For such protection, a work containing pornography must have some “redeemable” literary, artistic, or scientific merit.
  3. In your reasoned opinion, did the teacher act unethically in this case in showing the movie “Alexander” to her students? Why or why not?

    This is an opinion question, so student responses may vary. In your author’s opinion, the result of the sheriff’s investigation “speaks volumes” in this case. As indicated in the article, investigators determined the teacher had a legitimate reason (an educational purpose) for showing the film to her college-level classical studies students.